After Felony Conviction, Iraq War Veteran Faces Deportation To Mexico | Connecticut Public Radio
WNPR

After Felony Conviction, Iraq War Veteran Faces Deportation To Mexico

Apr 24, 2019
Originally published on April 24, 2019 3:54 pm

An Iraq War veteran who is not a U.S. citizen is facing deportation to Mexico over a felony conviction unless an immigration judge decides to let him stay in the United States.

Edgar Baltazar Garcia, 38, is husky and bearded, and he's physically larger than the Central American men who sit glumly beside him on a bench in immigration court in South Texas. The infantryman wore combat fatigues when he manned a .50-caliber machine gun — nicknamed Lucifer — in the turret of a Humvee when he served in Iraq 15 years ago. Today, his uniform is a red jail jumpsuit with the letters "PIDC" on the back — Port Isabel Detention Center.

At Baltazar's initial hearing, his attorney, Carlos Garcia, asks the judge to throw out the case. "He's an Iraqi War veteran who suffers from PTSD and is currently detained," Garcia tells the court. At the end of the hearing, the judge denies the motion, and Baltazar is led with the other detainees back to their cells.

The soldier, despite his service medals, got into some serious trouble after he came home from war.

In one incident last year, he pointed a handgun at his domestic partner; in a second incident, he punched her. She pressed charges. Baltazar was found guilty of "aggravated assault on a family member with a deadly weapon."

Because he served in Iraq, his case was moved to a special county court for veterans. There, he received a deferred sentence.

Things were going well. Baltazar was attending counseling sessions and passing drug and alcohol tests. In February, he drove across the border to Reynosa, Mexico, to see a nephew fight in a boxing match. The veterans court had approved the trip. But when he tried to return to Hidalgo, Texas, federal agents on the international bridge checked his record, spotted the felony and took him into custody.

The way immigration law works, his attorney explains, Baltazar could not be deported for his crime as long as he stayed in the United States. "But once you leave and you come back, it's a completely different ballgame," Garcia says, "because the rules at the port of entry are completely different for people who are entering the country and considered what they call 'arriving aliens.' "

Asked to comment on the case, a spokesperson for Immigration and Customs Enforcement said the agency is required to "detain and process for removal individuals who have been convicted of aggravated felonies as defined under the Immigration and Nationality Act."

Baltazar says on the phone from inside the razor-wire detention center, "U.S. citizens can go out and commit a crime — they never fought for their country —and they're not deported. I make one mistake, and I have to pay the price by leaving the country."

I make one mistake, and I have to pay the price by leaving the country. - Edgar Baltazar Garcia

Baltazar was born in Mexico. His parents brought him to the U.S. when he was 14. He was a lawful permanent resident of the U.S. when he joined the Army, but he never got around to getting naturalized. According to the Migration Policy Institute, 91,000 U.S. veterans are lawful residents who don't have their citizenship.

"I've got veterans right now who've been out of the military 30 years, and they're still not legal citizens. They need to do their paperwork," says Ricardo Peña, a veterans advocate in the Rio Grande Valley. "We call it in Spanish la desidia, meaning they don't do it because they're lazy, they forget about it."

Baltazar's woes are not a product of President Trump's crackdown on immigrants. The United States has been deporting convicted immigrant veterans since the Vietnam War, and for decades it has been sparking outrage.

Rep. Vicente Gonzalez, in whose South Texas district Baltazar lives, has introduced a bill called the Repatriate Our Patriots Act. It would prohibit the deportation of any honorably discharged veteran unless the veteran is convicted of homicide, rape, terrorism or child sex crimes.

"I think they should be punished for the crime they commit. If they have to go to jail, they have to go to jail. If they're on probation, they're on probation," Gonzalez says. "But we can't punish them twice. And we can't punish them permanently."

Gonzalez cited the case of Carlos Jaime Torres, a Vietnam War veteran in Texas who was convicted of marijuana dealing and deported in 2010. In December, he died in Reynosa, Mexico — where he'd been living in a cheap apartment.

"He passed away and came back in a casket and had a full military service burial. And I just find that very hypocritical of our government," says Gonzalez.

The extensive veterans' community in the Rio Grande Valley stands behind Baltazar.

"He should be tried and adjudicated by the criminal justice system he fought to maintain and not be deported," says Felix Rodriguez, who was an Army intelligence specialist in Vietnam. He attended Baltazar's hearing in immigration court, he says, in solidarity with a brother in arms.

A Veterans Affairs clinic diagnosed Baltazar with post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury as a result of his combat duty. Studies indicate that service members and veterans who show PTSD symptoms are at a greater risk of intimate partner violence.

Rodriguez says he sees it every week as an officer with the veterans court that was overseeing Baltazar's case. "Definitely, there's a correlation, a relationship, between PTSD and risky behavior that lands them in our veterans treatment court," he says.

As for the bill in Congress to stop deportations of veterans, its passage is a long shot. "I think the anti-immigrant climate affects my bill," says Gonzalez. "They see it as an immigration bill, which it's not. It's a veterans' rights bill."

Baltazar's final hearing is scheduled for the end of this month. The judge will decide either to deport him or to let him remain in the U.S. Says the vet, "I hope they take into consideration what I did for my country."

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

There are about 90,000 military veterans in this country who are not American citizens - that's according to the Migration Policy Institute. One of those veterans is a veteran of the Iraq War living in South Texas. He is now facing deportation over a felony conviction unless an immigration judge decides to let him stay. NPR's John Burnett has the story.

JOHN BURNETT, BYLINE: The army veteran is husky and bearded and physically bigger than the Central American men who sit glumly on a bench in immigration court. Edgar Baltazar Garcia wore combat fatigues when he manned a .50-caliber machine gun nicknamed Lucifer (ph) in the turret of a Humvee when he was in Iraq 15 years ago. Today, his uniform is a red jail jumpsuit with the letters PIDC on the back - Port Isabel Detention Center. The judge calls the court to order.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BARBARA GONZALEZ CIGARROA: This is the immigration court in Port Isabel, Texas. Immigration Judge Cigarroa presiding on March 6, 2019.

BURNETT: At this, the initial hearing, his attorney, Carlos Garcia, asks the judge to dismiss Baltazar's case.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

CARLOS MOCTEZUMA GARCIA: He's an Iraqi War (ph) veteran who suffers from PTSD and is currently detained.

BURNETT: The judge denies the motion to terminate the case, and Baltazar is led with the others back to their cells. The infantryman, despite his combat medals, got into some serious trouble after he came home from war. In one incident, he pointed a gun at his domestic partner. In a second incident, he punched her. She filed charges. Baltazar was found guilty of aggravated assault on a family member with a deadly weapon. Because he served in Iraq, his case was moved to a special county court for veterans. There, he received a deferred sentence.

Things were going well. Baltazar was attending counseling sessions and passing drug and alcohol tests. In February, he drove to Mexico to see a nephew fight in a boxing match. When he tried to return to Texas, federal agents checked his record, spotted the felony and took him into custody. His attorney, Carlos Garcia, says the way the law works, Baltazar could not be deported for his crime as long as he stayed in the U.S.

MOCTEZUMA GARCIA: But once you leave, and you come back, it's a completely different ball game because the rules at the port of entry are completely different for people who are entering the country and considered what they call arriving aliens.

BURNETT: Asked to comment on the case, a spokesperson for Immigration and Customs Enforcement referenced the Immigration and Nationality Act which says non-citizens who commit aggravated felonies are to be detained and processed for removal. Baltazar was born in Mexico. His parents brought him to the U.S. when he was 14. He never got around to getting his citizenship. Baltazar speaks on a tinny phone line from inside the razor-wired detention camp.

EDGAR BALTAZAR GARCIA: Then we have citizens born in this country that they can go out and commit a crime...

BURNETT: He says, U.S. citizens can go out and commit a crime. They never fought for their country, and they're not deported. I make one mistake, and I have to pay the price by leaving the country.

Edgar Baltazar's woes are not a product of President Trump's crackdown on immigrants. The United States has been deporting convicted immigrant veterans for decades, and for decades, it's been sparking outrage. Congressman Vicente Gonzalez, in whose South Texas district Baltazar lives, has introduced the bill called the Repatriate Our Patriots Act. It would prohibit the deportation of any honorably discharged veteran unless they're convicted of homicide, rape, terrorism or child sex crimes.

VICENTE GONZALEZ JR: And I think they should be punished for the crime that they commit. If they've got to go to jail, they've got to go to jail. If they're on probation, they're on probation. But we can't punish them twice, and we can't punish them permanently.

BURNETT: Gonzalez cited the case of Carlos Jaime Torres, a Vietnam vet who was convicted of marijuana dealing and deported in 2010. In December, he died in Reynosa, Mexico, where he'd been living in a cheap apartment.

GONZALEZ: Then he passed away and came back in a casket and had a full military service burial. And I just find that very hypocritical of our government.

BURNETT: The extensive veterans community in the Rio Grande Valley stands behind Edgar Baltazar.

FELIX RODRIGUEZ: He should be tried and adjudicated by the criminal justice system that he fought to maintain and not be deported.

BURNETT: Felix Rodriguez, a former Army intelligence specialist in Vietnam, attended Baltazar's hearing, he says, in solidarity with a brother-in-arms. The VA clinic in the Rio Grande Valley diagnosed Baltazar with post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury. Studies indicate that service members and veterans who show PTSD symptoms are at a greater risk of what's called intimate partner violence. Felix Rodriguez says he sees it every week as an officer with the veterans court that was overseeing Baltazar's case.

RODRIGUEZ: Definitely there's a correlation, a relationship, between PTSD and risky behavior that lands them in our veterans treatment court.

BURNETT: As for the bill in Congress to stop deportations of veterans, its passage is a long shot. The sponsor says, in this climate, anything seen as an immigration bill has a rough road. But the congressman stresses this isn't an immigration bill - it's a veterans' rights bill. Edgar Baltazar's final hearing is at the end of this month. The judge will decide either to deport him or let him stay in the U.S.

John Burnett, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.