© 2024 Connecticut Public

FCC Public Inspection Files:
WEDH · WEDN · WEDW · WEDY · WNPR
WPKT · WRLI-FM · WEDW-FM · Public Files Contact
ATSC 3.0 FAQ
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

A Debate Over How Much of GE’s Legacy Should Remain at Housatonic’s Bottom

Nancy Eve Cohen
/
NEPR
On the Housatonic River, there are signs warning people not to eat fish, frogs, turtles, and ducks because of PCB contamination.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has given people until this Monday to comment on a $613 million plan to finish a toxic waste cleanup of the Housatonic River.

General Electric would foot the bill. The company had a factory on the river in Pittsfield where, up until the 1970s, it released PCBs, a chemical compound now linked to cancer. In 2000, GE signed an agreement to clean it up, and there’s a debate over whether removing the PCBs will protect the environment or hurt it.

First Two Miles Finished

At one time, it seemed like PCBs were everywhere in Pittsfield. In the mid-1990s, resident Barbara Cianfarini learned dozens of backyards were contaminated. Walking above the Housatonic River, she pointed to a stretch south of the old GE plant that’s been cleaned up. “So if you look right in there you can see a little patch of water, you can see it running down there,” she said.

Congress banned PCBs or polychlorinated biphenyls in the late 1970s. Up until then, for decades, GE used them to make electrical transformers. Cianfarini, who helped start the group Citizens for PCB Removal, remembers smelling the PCBs. “It’s a very heavy, dank, oily smell,” she said. “I jokingly referred to it as Pittsfield’s bad breath.”

Credit Nancy Eve Cohen / NEPR
/
NEPR
A stretch of the Housatonic River that, under an EPA proposal, would be dredged to remove PCBs.

Pittsfield is cleaner now. Cianfarini said that in the seven years since the EPA and GE dug up PCBs from the first two miles of the river, the plants and animals have returned. “Mother Nature has taken over and camouflaged it very well,” she said. “So we’re very pleased with the results.”

Regulators Scale Back Ambitions for "Rest of River"

Downstream, a very different stretch of polluted river has yet to be cleaned up. The EPA’s plan covers 15 miles that flow past a state forest, an Audubon Sanctuary and the town of Lenox, home to Tanglewood.

In 2011, as the EPA was working on its plan, the state of Massachusetts criticized the federal agency for proposing to dig up PCBs where there are rare species.

Curt Spalding, who heads up the EPA in New England, said the EPA’s plan has shifted. “We were going to do more. We’re doing a little less, but we’re still meeting the criteria,” Spalding said. “What I mean by a little less: a little less digging and capping in sensitive areas that the state was concerned about, but overall, it meets the criteria, and that’s the bottom line.” He was referring to the federal criteria designed to protect human health and the environment.

Spalding said the plan removes enough PCBs so that eventually, the fish will be safe enough to eat. PCBs, which settle in the soil, are ingested by insects, which are consumed by fish. Other animals, including humans, eat the fish and get exposed to the toxin. “We don’t see a future at this point where pregnant women or children can just eat the fish freely,” he said. “What we’re shooting for is one fish a month for healthy adults and teenagers and above.”

The Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection declined to be interviewed at this point in the process. General Electric released a statement referring to “significant flaws” in the plan.

No Easy Answers, No Consensus

Six towns in the area are concerned about the economic and social impacts. In Connecticut, where the Housatonic flows into Long Island Sound, a state biologist said the plan does a good job addressing the reduction of PCBs that come down stream.

Credit Nancy Eve Cohen / NEPR
/
NEPR
Jeffrey Cook, who lives near the Housatonic River, says digging it up to remove PCBs will destroy sensitive habitat.

The public is also divided.

Jeffrey Cook has lived in the Berkshires near the river for decades. He acknowledged that removing PCBs could help wildlife. “But the human health risk is enormously overstated and most of us really think it’s a lot of baloney,” said Cook, who leads a group that’s concerned about the EPA’s plan.

Cook lives in a house overlooking an expansive floodplain and miles of tangled wetlands. He said the landscape will be destroyed. “You’re now walking through the most beautiful area and the most sensitive,” he said on a walk through the woods. The path stops at the river’s edge. “They’re dredging the whole river in this area. So everything you see bank to bank is going to be dug out,” 

South of here, Tim Gray of the Housatonic River Initiative was paddling past October Mountain, admiring the fall colors. “It does make you think, ‘Why should we clean the river?’ because it’s beautiful,” he said. “But down below this river, although it looks beautiful, lies a deadly toxin.”

Credit Nancy Eve Cohen / NEPR
/
NEPR
Housatonic River Keeper Tim Gray has been fighting for a thorough clean-up of the river for decades.

Gray has been fighting for a thorough clean up for nearly 40 years. He said the EPA’s plan doesn’t clean up enough PCBs. “We find it absurd that we want to leave super-high levels of PCBs in there that are not good for these state-listed species, especially the animals,” he said.

Gray admits a clean up is a construction project, but he pointed to the PCB removal in Pittsfield as proof that the river can recover. He wants the EPA to slow down and test new ways to treat and destroy PCBs without hurting habitat. “It took them 70 years, whatever it is to pollute the river and start cleaning it up,” Gray said. “And guess what? I’m not in a hurry. And the bottom line is maybe we put that off until we can figure out really the best thing to do for it.”

Once the EPA finalizes its plan, GE has the right to dispute it. Either way, it could be years before the cleanup begins.

This story was originally published at NEPR.net.

Stand up for civility

This news story is funded in large part by Connecticut Public’s Members — listeners, viewers, and readers like you who value fact-based journalism and trustworthy information.

We hope their support inspires you to donate so that we can continue telling stories that inform, educate, and inspire you and your neighbors. As a community-supported public media service, Connecticut Public has relied on donor support for more than 50 years.

Your donation today will allow us to continue this work on your behalf. Give today at any amount and join the 50,000 members who are building a better—and more civil—Connecticut to live, work, and play.

Related Content